| ON 29 JANUARY, the Court of Appeal found Sally Clark
innocent of the murder of two of her sons. She had spent more than three
years in prison, away from her husband and remaining son. Her innocence
had been proclaimed in the House of Lords on 17 October 2001, yet she spent
another 15 months in jail.
I (too) had been the subject of a witch-hunt, when our son developed
post viral fatigue following pneumonia. This developed into Chronic Fatigue
Syndrome, known as CFS/ME. I was suspected of abusing our son, by supposedly
inventing or causing his illness (“over-anxious parenting”).
An extremely expensive and time-consuming child-protection inquiry
was undertaken, during which both our children were briefly on the “At
risk” register, and we feared that they could be taken from us.
As in Sally Clark’s case, we were eventually cleared because
we were educated and middle class, with connections. We could fight. Our
children’s names were removed from the register when a senior councillor
and our MP, both of whom knew us, spoke up for us. Most of the people
wrongly accused have nobody to speak up for them, and are not able to
fight so well. In the Lords debate in October 2001, several speakers drew
parallels between false accusations of child abuse and medieval witch
trials. On Thursday 13 02 03, a BBC documentary, Cot Death Mothers: The
witch-hunt strongly criticised the part played by some expert witnesses,
in particular, Professor Sir Roy Meadow. Other experts are also being
investigated.
In a paper to the United Campaigns Against False Allegations of Abuse
(UCAAFA) conference in November, the distinguished social-work consultant
Charles Pragnell quoted research findings that the effect of false allegation
is not a benign or neutral process, but causes long-term damage to children.
This was true for us. Our daughter, who was five at the time we were investigated,
lost much of her sense of independence and became fearful of being taken
from me; this has never been fully regained. I overheard two of her friends
plotting how they would rescue her if she were taken into care.
Jan Loxley Blount . Church Times. 21 02 03
|